Gator Bowl

1951

 

Wyoming 34

Washington & Lee 18

Wyoming Fight Song

 

The 1951 Gator Bowl was a battle of two different offenses and one nasty defense. The Washington and Lee Generals were rolling with the new split "T'' formation and threatened to run through Wyoming's defense.

Led by quarterback Gil Bocetti and future NFL All-Pro linebacker Walt Michaels, W&L marched through the regular season with an 8-2 record and a 5-0 mark in the Southern Conference to win the league title. With Bocetti running the show and Michaels at fullback, the Generals had a potent offense that averaged over 30 points a game. The only losses that season were a 26-21 setback to archrival Virginia and a 27-20 loss at Tennessee. Tennessee, which finished the season ranked fourth in the country, scored three of its touchdowns on returns and was outgained by over 120 yards in the contest. On the season, Michaels averaged six yards per carry, scored 10 touchdowns and kicked 29 extra points. W&L, coached by George Barclay, was rewarded with its first and only trip a post-season bowl game. But W&L star, Michaels, was bedridden with appendicitis. Lea Booth '40, W&L's sports publicist, accused the doctor, a physician at the University of Virginia, of keeping him out of the game. "It was the first game I'd ever missed," said Michaels. "Lea Booth always thought there was some kind of conspiracy behind it." In addition, the death of Bocetti's father just days before the game affected the quarterback, as well as the entire team.

Wyoming, the undefeated champions of the Mountain States Conference, had rolled through the season undefeated. Coached by the legendary Bowden Wyatt, it was arguably the finest season in Wyoming football history. The Wyoming single wing offense was operating better than ever behind tailback Eddie Talboom. The Cowboy defense, tops in the nation heading into the game, was handed a challenge when W & L supporters doubted its toughness and questioned the UW schedule. The Generals had a big and physical defensive front, and the Cowboys had trouble penetrating the wall.

The first quarter ended scoreless, but UW had figured out how to beat the W&L crew. If you can't run through them, throw over them. Wyoming started a drive late in the first period, using the passing skills of Talboom and the receiving gifts of Dewey McConnell and Jerry Parker. The Cowboys moved the ball to the General 8-yard line, where Talboom tossed a touchdown to back Dick Campbell, who was wide open in the endzone. Talboom kicked the point after and UW led, 7-0 (video). After an excellent defensive stand by the Cowboys, the Generals were forced to pass, and Selmer Pederson picked off the ball at the UW 47-yard line. Talboom went back to work, hitting on three straight passes for 45 yards and putting the Cowboys in scoring position. A pass interference penalty put the ball on the General 2-yard line, and Talboom carried it in from there. He missed the point after, but the Pokes extended their lead, 13-0 (video). The Generals got their offense moving late in the second quarter and moved to the UW 21-yard line. On fourth down and long, Ray Leister's pass attempt to Talbot Trammel sailed out of the endzone, and the half came to a close.

W&L got the ball to start the second half and moved with ease against the Cowboy defense. Wes Abrams ran for 22 yards, and Charlie Holt followed that with a 30-yard run to the Cowboy 25-yard line where he was hit and fumbled. Vaughn Hilpp recovered for the Pokes and stopped the scoring threat. After taking a Wyoming punt, the Generals moved backward on three straight plays, including a 16-yard loss on an errant pitch. Punting from his 5-yard line, Leister's kick went just 20 yards, and Wyoming had the ball on the W&L 25. After a 2-yard loss, Talboom found McConnell for 9 yards. Fullback John Melton ran up the middle for 18 yards and a touchdown. Talboom made the point after, and Wyoming's lead grew to 20-0 (video). The Generals scored late in the fourth quarter on a 2-yard quarterback-sneak by Gil Bocetti (video). The Cowboys ran out the clock after the ensuing kick-off. The Cowboys had prevented the Generals from scoring, but gave up 252 rushing yards to Washington and Lee's Split T. Talboom was awarded the game's MVP.

Wyoming finished the season ranked #10 in the nation and W&L finished #18. Wyoming was just the second conference team ever to win a bowl game and vowed it wouldn't be too long before it returned to a postseason classic. For Washington & Lee, it was the one and only appearance in a college bowl game.

Coming into the 1950 season, Washington and Lee was feeling the financial pressure of being a very small school competing against larger schools to maintain their status among football's elite. In spite of such financial barriers, in 1951 the Blue Train steamrolled over larger schools and catapulted into the national spotlight. The University received a bowl payout of $27,500 for the Gator Bowl and this helped in the short term. The little Lexington, Virginia school would have to face up to its own alarming athletic excesses. The traumatic results were felt throughout college football. In 1954, most of the football squad was involved in a highly publicized cheating scandal. The university swiftly cracked down. A debate was launched as to the future of athletics at the institution.

The answer came on July 23, 1954, when the Board of Trustees ended the subsidization of athletes at W&L. The rest of the athletic program would continue, but football as W&L knew it was gone. The University had no choice but to eliminate big-time college football. If W&L competed today at college football's Division I-A level, it would have the smallest undergraduate enrollment with 1,746 students; by comparison, Wake Forest holds that spot with 3,748 undergraduates. Lexington lacks an airport; the closest city, Roanoke, is nearly 60 miles away; and the population hovers at around 6,800. Under those circumstances, it would be difficult, if not impossible, to sell enough tickets, not to mention land a television contract. Looking back, "it was inevitable with the limited student body and small stadium," said Michaels, "that Washington and Lee couldn't survive." Today, Washington and Lee competes successfully at the Div III level. But, her fans remember a time, not so long ago, when the Generals played in a New Years Day bowl game.
 

 

Action from the Gator Bowl.

 

Walt Michaels, Joe McCutcheon, Don Ferguson and Buck Conrad of W&L.

 

MVP Eddie Talboom. Wyoming Cheerleaders.

 

Wyoming's media guide.

 

Attendance-10,834

Scoring Summary
 

First Quarter
WYO- Campbell 8-yard pass from Talboom (Talboom kick)

Second Quarter
WYO- Talboom 2-yard run (kick failed),

Third Quarter
WYO- Melton 18-yard run (Talboom kick)

Fourth Quarter
W&L- Bocetti 2-yard run (Brewer kick)

Individual Statistics

Rushing
WYO- Geldien 11-56, Melton 12-49, Talboom 14-31
W&L- Holt 21-107, Broyles 12-89, Abrams 7-42

Passing
WYO- Talboom 10-16-141
W&L- Bocetti 3-12-31

 

Home

Next