The Shamrock Bowl
Houston, TX
December 17, 1949


The final game in the history of the All America Football Conference (1946-1949) is generally regarded as the final championship game that took place on December 11, 1949 at Municipal Stadium in Cleveland, Ohio. In that game, the Cleveland Browns would win their fourth consecutive AAFC title. The Browns were the only team to ever win the AAFC championship, having won it four straight years from 1946 through 1949. In that final championship game, the Browns defeated the San Francisco 49ers, 21-7. But, this was not the final game in AAFC history. The final game actually occurred on December 17, 1949 at the Shamrock Charity Bowl All-Star Game at Rice Stadium in Houston, TX.

The National Football League and the All-America Football Conference had fought a nasty bidding war for players in the 1940’s, but the sides had called a truce on December 11, 1949 when they announced a merger. The Browns and 49ers, along with the Baltimore Colts, would all be merged into the NFL for the 1950 season. The other AAFC teams ceased to be as the Buffalo Bills were merged with the Browns, the New York Yankees were split among the New York Giants and the New York Bulldogs and the Los Angeles Dons mixed with the L.A. Rams. The only team left out in the cold were the Chicago Rockets, who were disbanded.

For the City of Houston, there was hope that the formation of the new National-American Football League would bring an expansion team to South Texas. Glenn "Diamond Glenn" McCarthy, Houston oil tycoon, announced that he would sponsor an AAFC All-Star Game as a charity event to raise money for Holly Hall (Home for the Aged) of Houston, the Damon Runyon Cancer Fund and National Kids Day Foundation. In 1949, McCarthy had opened his $21 million Shamrock Hotel on St. Patrick’s Day. McCarthy owned many companies, over 400 gas and oil wells in Texas and was president of the United States Petroleum Association. McCarthy was a visionary Houstonian who loved his community and football.  He dreamed of Houston being a professional football town.  He had been tentatively assured of a new franchise by the AAFC, but that promise faded away with the merger.   He was also a well connected man whose friends included Hollywood celebrities. His Shamrock Bowl would give the community exposure and expose the community to professional football. The city had never before hosted a professional football game of this magnitude. It was McCarthy’s Shamrock Bowl that would be the curtain call for the AAFC.

The game, which would pit the champion of the AAFC against a team of all-stars selected from the other six AAFC franchises, was the only all-star contest in the league’s history. An imposing array of talent was picked for the game. The Cleveland Browns qualified by defeating the 49ers and they boasted perhaps the greatest team in the history of professional football to that point. The Browns went 14-0 in 1948 and were, along with the 1972 Miami Dolphins, one of only two teams in professional football history to accomplish an undefeated season. Led by quarterback, Otto Graham, and coached by the legendary Paul Brown, the Browns had posted a 56-4-3 record in their history. Stars for the Browns included fullback, Marion Motley, ends, Dante Lavelli, Mac Speedie and John Yonakor and center, Lou Saban. The All-Stars were led by rookie sensation, Y.A. Tittle, at quarterback from the Baltimore Colts, fullback, Joe Perry of San Francisco, and halfbacks, Buddy Young and Tom Landry of the New York Yankees. The All-Stars were coached by Red Strader of the Yankees and he and his assistants arrived in Houston about ten days before the game to begin the preparation. Strader’s Yankees had lost a semi-final playoff game to San Francisco. The Browns arrived in Houston by rail on December 14, three days after their championship game victory in Cleveland. The Houston citizens were excited that the Browns arrived so soon and began to limber up at the Stadium just hours after checking in at the Shamrock. The weather in Houston during the week was disappointing, rainy and cold. But, Paul Brown had no problem with the elements having just come from miserable conditions the week before in Cleveland. When asked upon arrival if the rains would alter his team’s practice plans, Brown responded, “I don’t see why it should. We have been practicing and playing in rain all season.” Houston was so focused on the game that the Houston Chronicle headline following the AAFC championship read, “Browns Brush Aside 49ers To Qualify For Bowl Game.”

 

Houston Chronicle
 

The game was scheduled for a 2:00 pm kick-off with entertainment preceding it at 1:00 by radio stars, Jack Benny, Phil Harris (who starred on the Jack Benny Show) and Dinah Shore. The three entertained the crowd of 12,000 in a downpour. Benny wore a Shamrock Hotel patrolman’s raincoat and was munching on a hotdog. The fans, although small in number, were very enthusiastic about professional football coming to Houston.

The first ten minutes of the game was a mud brawl as neither team threatened. After two failed offensive series for the Stars, Coach Strader pulled quarterback George Ratterman of Buffalo in favor of San Francisco’s Frankie Albert. Late in the first period, the All-Stars mounted a drive. Albert led the Stars on a 16 play drive starting from his own 32. Albert          passed for 40 yards on the drive, connecting on passes to Chet Mutryn of Buffalo and Lamar Davis of the Colts to move the ball to the 26 yard line of the Browns. He then hit Otto Schnellenbacher of the Yankees for a first down at the 15. Buddy Young of the Yankees picked up 5 yards to the 9 and Joe Perry of the 49ers got five and a first down at the four. From there, Mutryn carried twice for the score. His touchdown coming on a two yard dive into the end zone with 1 ½ minutes to play in the first quarter. Albert’s extra point was blocked by the Browns’ line and the Stars led 6-0.

On the last play of the first quarter, the Browns Marion Motley burst through the line a jaunted 59 yards. He was brought down on the Stars 25 yard line. The Browns surged on the ground to the 2 yard line, but were held on a goal line stand at the one. The All-Stars were forced to punt from deep in their own territory. The Yankees’ Tom Landry punted to Cliff Lewis who returned it to the Stars’ 40. On the first play, Graham hit Dub Jones who took it in at the five and skidded across the goal line. Lou Groza’s extra point made the score 7-6 in favor of the Browns.

On the ensuing kick off, the Stars were assessed a penalty for clipping and had to start at their own 9 yard line. From there, the Stars mounted a 91 yard drive on 12 plays behind the passing of Albert and the running of Young. The big play of the drive came from the Browns’ 26, when Young shot off tackle, sprinted to his right and took the ball 23 yards to the Cleveland 13. After a loss of 2 on first down, Albert, completely surrounded by Browns, passed to Al Baldwin of Buffalo who shook off defenders at the 5 and carried it in for a 25 yard touchdown. The score was 12-7 at the half.

In the second half, the defenses played to a stalemate in the mud. The Browns threatened three times in the fourth quarter. Early in the period, the Browns drove from the All-Stars 44 to the 16, but Jim Cason of San Francisco intercepted a Graham pass. With eight minutes left, the Browns got a huge break when Young fumbled a pitch out from Albert and George Young recovered at the Stars’ 21. But, on fourth down from the 17, Graham’s pass to Edgar Jones was knocked down by Pete Layden of the Yankees. The Browns got one more chance starting at their own 32 after a punt late in the game. With passes to Dante Lavelli (29 yards) and Tom James (12 yards), Graham moved the champions to the All-Star 29. But, the Stars sacked Graham for a ten yard loss on first down and held the Browns from there. The final was 12-7.  The All-Star defense put pressure on Graham all day. It was unusual for the Browns to encounter such stern resistance in their short history. Graham was sacked for 55 yards in losses. It was only the fifth loss in franchise history.

 

It was the first game in the city's history that the players and the fans in the stands were integrated.  The newspapers of the day noted the lack of racism among the Houston crowd as Buddy Young received the loudest cheers throughout the afternoon. He was the leading ground gainer on the day, rushing for 75 yards in 12 carries as the All-Stars out-rushed the Browns 162-82 yards. The Browns’ Motley rushed for 69 yards in 8 carries. Graham was 8 of 19 passing for 101 yards. Albert completed 6 of 13 for 70 yards.

The crowd was amazed at the professional spectacle. They remained throughout the afternoon, in spite of the weather. One fan was asked if she liked the game. She said, “Did I like the game? I sat through it didn’t I?” Jess Neely, coach of the Rice Owls was impressed at the tenacious play by the pros, given the rough weather. It was the last game at the old Rice Stadium. A new 50,000 seat Stadium was to open the next season. It was the final game in the history of the AAFC and may have been a fitting ending. The Browns had dominated their league like no team before or since. The All-Stars took the opportunity to show their abilities and to prove that the talent in the league was not confined to the Cleveland organization solely. The Browns would survive this loss to win the world championship in their 1950, Cinderella season in the NFL. McCarthy’s dream of professional football for Houston would come to pass, but her citizens would have to wait 11 years for the formation of another upstart league, the American Football League, and the Houston Oilers.

 

(A special thanks to Greg Bond, Department Head of Vocational Nursing at Temple College, for the program image above.)

 

To view summaries of all AAFC championships games, click HERE.

 


RETURN